Addiction and Incarceration in New Mexico: How to Break the Cycle

This article is part of my series on addiction, recovery, and incarceration in Albuquerque and New Mexico.

In July 2024, New Mexico’s Legislative Finance Committee put two numbers side by side, and together they explain a big part of the state’s criminal justice problem.

The first number was 65%. That is the share of New Mexico’s incarcerated population with a substance use disorder. The second number was 9%, the share of the general population with one.1

Read those again. People in New Mexico’s jails and prisons are roughly seven times more likely to have a substance use disorder than people on the outside. The same report found that 59% of the incarcerated population has a mental health disorder.1

And the problem is not shrinking. In Albuquerque, drug offenses rose 116% in a single year, from 2,555 in 2022 to 4,749 in 2023.1

The committee’s conclusion was direct: for offenders with addiction, substance use disorder treatment is the most effective way to break the cycle of crime.1

I see that cycle every week. Men who used, committed crimes to keep using, went to jail, came out with no plan, used again, and went back. Addiction and incarceration in New Mexico are not two separate problems. They are one loop.

So how does that loop work? Why does it keep spinning? And what actually breaks it?

How the Loop of Addiction and Incarceration in New Mexico Works

The cycle of addiction and incarceration usually follows a familiar pattern.

It starts with substance use that grows into addiction. Addiction makes it hard to keep a job, pay rent, or stay connected to family. To keep using, some people steal, sell drugs, or get involved in other crimes. The legislative report noted research linking drug use to theft committed to fund drug purchases.1

Then comes arrest and jail or prison. Inside, the person may get sober because drugs are harder to get, but often without real treatment. Then they are released, frequently with no home, no job, no ID, and the same untreated addiction. They return to the same neighborhood and the same people. They use again. And the loop starts over.

Along the way, the people around them get pulled in too. Children grow up with a parent in and out of their lives. Partners and parents spend money, time, and hope trying to help. Neighborhoods feel the effects through property crime and lost trust.

Each time around, it gets harder to break. Records pile up. Family relationships wear thin. Jobs become harder to find.

Jail can pause addiction. Only treatment and support can end it.

The Numbers Behind the Revolving Door

New Mexico’s recidivism numbers show how often this loop repeats. The state’s three year recidivism rate was 40% as of early fiscal year 2024, compared to a national average of 27%. Of the roughly 3,000 people released from New Mexico prisons each year, about 1,200 are expected to reoffend within three years.1

Another legislative review found that most returns to prison come from new charges or absconding, not technical violations, which account for only about 20% of returns.2 In other words, people mostly go back because their lives fall apart after release, not because of paperwork.

That points straight back to addiction, housing, and support.

The Deadly Gap After Release

The loop is not just expensive. It is deadly.

Time inside lowers a person’s tolerance to drugs. When people with addiction are released and return to using, especially in a drug supply full of fentanyl, the risk of overdose skyrockets. A landmark study in the New England Journal of Medicine found that in the first two weeks after release from prison, the risk of death was nearly 13 times higher than for the general population, with drug overdose as a leading cause.3

In New Mexico, where fentanyl and meth now drive most overdose deaths, that gap is especially dangerous. The danger keeps growing, from fentanyl in Albuquerque to meth and fentanyl in New Mexico.

The Mental Health Piece

Addiction rarely travels alone. Remember that 59% of New Mexico’s incarcerated population has a mental health disorder.1 Many people have both: depression, anxiety, trauma, or serious mental illness alongside addiction.

That matters because untreated mental health conditions often drive substance use. People drink or use to quiet anxiety, numb trauma, or escape depression. If someone gets sober but their trauma is never addressed, the pain that fueled their addiction is still there waiting when they walk out.

Breaking the cycle means treating the whole person. At Troopers, every man meets a primary care provider, a psychiatry provider, and a therapist in his first weeks, along with daily peer support. Housing alone helps. Housing plus mental health care helps a lot more. Men can also connect with community providers like DRGMED for medical care and medication management, and Dr. Gloria O’Neill for mental health support.

What Breaks the Cycle

If addiction is the engine of this loop, then treating addiction is the most direct way to stop it. Here is what I have seen work.

Treatment inside. Jails and prisons that offer real addiction treatment, including medication for opioid use disorder, give people a head start. MDC in Albuquerque has offered a licensed opioid treatment program since 2009 and added buprenorphine maintenance in 2021.4 The same thread runs through starting recovery inside MDC.

Treatment instead of incarceration. Treatment courts and diversion programs can send people to recovery instead of prison. The legislative committee estimates treatment courts return about $4 for every $1 spent when implemented effectively.1 That is exactly how treatment courts in Bernalillo County work.

Continuity at release. Leaving with medication, active health coverage, and a treatment appointment closes the deadly gap. New Mexico now pauses Medicaid during incarceration instead of ending it, which helps.

Safe housing. A sober, structured home after release replaces the old environment with a new one. That is the reason Troopers exists. Our team wrote about reentry housing in Albuquerque and parole housing in New Mexico.

Work and purpose. A job, education, and a sense of purpose give people something to protect. That idea ties closely to second chance jobs in Albuquerque.

Community. Peer support, recovery meetings, and family connection keep people from walking the road alone.

What I See Every Week

The numbers can feel abstract, so let me tell you what the loop looks like up close.

A man arrives at one of our homes a few days out of jail. He is quiet at first, unsure whether to trust anyone. Within a few weeks, he is going to groups, seeing his care team, and talking about getting his ID. Some days are hard. Some days he wants to quit. But slowly, the routine takes hold.

Around day 100, he starts working. A few months later, he is helping the new guy who just walked in the door. Around a year in, he moves into a place of his own.

Not every story goes that way. Recovery is not a straight line. But I have seen enough of those stories to know the loop can be broken, one man at a time.

Why Punishment Alone Does Not Work

For decades, much of the response to addiction has been punishment. Arrest people, lock them up, and hope they learn their lesson.

The data says that approach, by itself, does not work for people with addiction. Addiction changes the brain. It is a chronic health condition, not simply a choice. You cannot punish a medical condition out of someone, any more than you could punish diabetes out of them.

Accountability still matters. People should face consequences for the harm they cause. But accountability works best when it comes with treatment. Treatment courts are a good example: they combine judicial oversight and consequences with real addiction care.

When we only punish, we pay for the same prison bed again and again. When we treat, we have a chance to stop paying.

What Families and Communities Can Do About Addiction and Incarceration in New Mexico

You do not have to be a judge or a lawmaker to help break this cycle.

If someone you love is incarcerated, encourage them to seek treatment inside and help them plan a safe release. You can see the same pattern in what to do when a loved one is incarcerated. If you are an employer, consider hiring people with records. If you are a landlord, consider renting to people in recovery. If you are a voter, pay attention to whether your leaders fund treatment, housing, and reentry programs.

Every one of those choices helps someone step out of the loop.

The Bottom Line About Addiction and Incarceration in New Mexico

“Substance use disorder treatment is the most effective way to break the cycle of crime.”

New Mexico Legislative Finance Committee, 2024

Sixty five percent of the people in New Mexico’s jails and prisons have a substance use disorder. Until we treat that addiction, we will keep watching the same people cycle through the same system, at enormous cost to families, communities, and taxpayers.

The good news is that we know what works: treatment inside, treatment instead of incarceration when it makes sense, continuity at release, safe housing, work, and community.

If a man you love is coming home and needs a free, sober place to land in Albuquerque, you can apply to Troopers or call (305) 450-8763.

What would New Mexico look like if we treated addiction before we punished it?

Footnotes

  1. Update on Crime in New Mexico and Bernalillo County, New Mexico Legislative Finance Committee, July 2024.
  2. Corrections Reentry and Supervision Programming, New Mexico Legislative Finance Committee, December 2024.
  3. Release from Prison: A High Risk of Death for Former Inmates, Binswanger et al., New England Journal of Medicine, 2007.
  4. BayMark Expands Treatment Options at New Mexico Metropolitan Detention Center, BayMark Health Services, September 2021.

Thanks for reading. You can get more in my free newsletter. Every issue comes with a short essay about my week, 5 notes on recovery, addiction, reentry, homelessness, and incarceration, 4 voices, 3 resources, 2 wins, and 1 question for you.

Join the newsletter

About Me

German Urrego, a dad, dreamer, doer, President of Troopers, and Piolingo, helping New Mexico recover from addiction.